Online ordering powered by Seamless
796 Ninth Ave, (B/W W 52nd St & W 53rd St)(212) 247-8400
Pickup estimate is 10-15 min (more info)
Unfortunately, Holey Cream is not open at the delivery/pickup time that you selected. Please make sure that you've entered an address and try changing the time in the Order Information section to the right.
Estimated pickup time is 20-25 min (more info)
Print this menu
Choice of two or more flavors.
Ice Cream by the pint.
Holey Cream is well known in Midtown for offering unique and outstanding sweet treats. Holey Cream is open late so that no matter what time you’re craving a delicious treat, they can always satisfy your hunger. The Specialty Sundaes, Ice Cream Donut Sandwiches, and Milk Shakes are all prepared quickly and delivered to you right away. Holey Cream uses only the freshest ingredients around, ensuring that every dish is of the highest possible quality. Be sure to try the best selling Fat Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Ice Cream and see why customers are always coming back for more. Order online or stop by Holey Cream today!
Absolutely atrocious. Took 2.5 hrs to deliver two frozen yogurts. I called several times to check the status of my order (and eventually cancel) and the response was giggling and reassurances that the delivery man is on his way. Had the delivery been using a scooter in 2 feet of snow, I would've believed that "he was on his way." Additionally, despite an attempt to cancel my order, "management" insisted the order was on its way and had no way of contacting the delivery man. The sundaes came mostly liquid, spilled everywhere and ruined my beautiful Sputnik Walnut midcentury table. If seamless hadn't been so kind to refund my order, I'd be outside picketing this horrid institution.
Posted a year ago by Elliot S.
Took 2 hours + to deliver, and forgot part of my order.
Would not recommend, there are much better choices on seamless at these prices.
Posted 2 years ago by Eric H.
LOVE, LOVE , LOVE THIS PLACE! I WAS WORKING LATE IN THE OFFICE ON A SATURDAY NIGHT, AND WAS CRAVING SOMETHING SWEET. CAME ACROSS HOLEY CREAM AND BOY DID THE STRAWBERRY DOUGHNUT AND MILKSHAKE PICK ME UP! LOOKING FORWARD TO ORDERING FROM THEM AGAIN SOON!
Posted 2 years ago by R S.
Horrible delivery time and rude workers not worth it
Posted 2 years ago by Michelle L.
Seriously overrated on here. Don't get me wrong, the LI Raspberry Ice Cream was delicious but the other two flavors we ordered were seriously meh. We ordered a pint of each and the pint of the Belgian chocolate wasn't even a full container.... Moreover there were ice chips throughout... I seriously got the bottom of the barrel. The Nutella doughnut was nothing to write home about, better can be found at 7 Eleven. Overall, don't spend your money on something that can be bought for much much cheaper elsewhere. It gets two stars for the one good flavor of ice cream...but even that was lacking the mixins it was supposed to have. Won't be ordering again.
Posted 2 years ago by Lila N.
Holey Cream is amazing. They were prompt and their donuts were spectacular. We will continue to be loyal customers :)
Posted 2 years ago by adam d.
I have ordered from Holey Cream twice. The first time they took 2 hours to deliver. They gave me some sob story about the delivery guy quitting and them having to find someone to make the delivery, and I bought it and was totally understanding. But tonight when I called to find out where my food was after an hour and a half only to discover it hadn't even left yet and they gave me the same lie about the delivery guy I was enraged. If you actually want your food within a couple of hours of when you order it, don't order from Holey Cream!
Posted 2 years ago by Mellissa S.
This place never gets my order right!! This is going to sound like the most ridiculous review, but this has happened so many times. Just tonight I ordered strawberry donuts with rainbow sprinkles and they sent me vanilla donuts with chocolate sprinkles. I am not a chocolate fan. Dessert ruined... possibly life.
Posted 2 years ago by Michael P.
Normally don't write reviews but ridiculous. Estimated 35 minute wait time, around the corner from where I live...2 hours later and still not here. Called and they keep saying it's "on the way..."
Posted 2 years ago by Kasey L.
mediocre grease tasting donuts, ice cream is overrated. not tasty at all
Posted 2 years ago by Katey K.
They only delivered some of the order. The rest of the order took over two hours, three total.
Posted 2 years ago by David G.
I ordered at 8.50pm then called twice to check on the order as it was over 2 hours late. They told me the food was on its way but it never arrived.
Posted 2 years ago by Beau G.
Don't expect late night delivery to come on time... Ordered a pair of milkshakes and it took over an hour and a half :/
Posted 2 years ago by William M.
This place is kind of expensive for what it is, and you can end up spending $14 for a Sundae when you include the tax, delivery few and tip. However, the ice cream has always been tasty and it's never arrived a sloppy mess. The big winner here, as with most places that deliver in NYC is the convenience. The make-your-own donut option is fun and delish.
Posted 2 years ago by Dominique D.
Delivered an incomplete order, called to ask them what happened. Then the guy on the phone gave me some serious attitude and told me it would be delivered in 10 minutes. Waited over an hour and it still hasn't arrived. Don't bother with these clowns. Oh and the worst part is they're literally 2 blocks away from my apartment.
Posted 2 years ago by Jeffrey Z.
The ice cream and frozen yogurt are delicious, but sometimes the orders come incorrectly and a bit later than the time frame given.
Posted 2 years ago by Beth L.
Delicious sundaes!!! Ha ha ha had a fair share.... They sometimes come late... If your sundae is melted send it back!!
Posted 2 years ago by Chip S.
Usually pretty good, but they sed a brownie and not a doughnut. This was a sad delivery. :-(
Posted 2 years ago by Denice A.
Neighborhood gem! Love their low fat peanut butter twist!
Posted 2 years ago by Jennifer c.
Top notch. Exciting desert menu. Fast delivery. Many choices. Every time you want something sweet, this is the place to go. A+
Posted 2 years ago by George A.
OMG. BEST ICE CREAM SELECTION EVER!!!!!
Posted 2 years ago by Gallery 57 D.
I Seamless nearly every day, and Holey Cream is the only restaurant that causes regular problems. I had ignored the incorrect order deliveries, the frequent and unfriendly calls to say that they did not have the items I ordered available, and the typically late delivery. However, today was the last straw: The delivery person got into a loud and aggressive altercation with my (highly professional) doormen. Truly unacceptable service--a shame, given the genuinely good quality of their food.
Posted 2 years ago by Nicholas E.
The best ice cream and deliver is always quick!
Posted 2 years ago by alina o.
The donuts sandwich is truly amazing!!!! By far my favorite treat.
Posted 2 years ago by Aurora C.
Great ice cream and brownies! Banana split is yum!
Posted 2 years ago by Joe L.
Consistency of ice cream changed yet ordered same flavor. Always has been super expensive of ice cream delivery. There is a delivery charge and then a tip. I will probably still order from them but you pay a lot for what you get.
Posted 2 years ago by Leah D.
Always amazing, solid delivery time, all around great!
Posted 2 years ago by Aaron F.
Very good homemade ice cream
Posted 2 years ago by Julie A.
The people who work here are rude and disorganized. Delivery took more than 2 hours and I'm 2 blocks away. When I called to complain, they said it was already delivered but it never came.
Posted 2 years ago by Robert C.
Ordering here since I moved to an apartment nearby 2.5 years ago. They got rid if my favorite flavor froyo. Fortunately, there are other flavors almost just as good! Great cones and sprinkles. We order from here once or twice a week. Will miss it when we move in the fall! Delivery has gotten so much better. They call if they run out if the flavor we want. Donuts okay. We're always satisfied!
Posted 2 years ago by Mel G.
NEVER DELIVERS ON TIME
Posted 2 years ago by ryan B.
This place USED to be good and I ordered from them a couple of times a week plus recommended them to my friends. That said, their customer service is now inept and rude and delivery takes too long and that's IF you receive it at all. Tonight I waited OVER THREE AND-A-HALF HOURS without receiving my order! I called them twice during that time - the first time after I had been waiting for 2 hours. At that point they lied to me and said my order was on it's way. An hour later I hadn't received it so I called them again. At that point they didn't answer the phone initially and when they did the guy who I had talked to before was extremely rude. He forgot he had discussed my order with me the previous time I called and denied receiving my order and said that Seamless must have made a mistake. As I write this it has been FOUR hours since I placed that order and during that time I had dinner guests waiting for the delivery so they could have dessert and I have had an upsetting night instead of a fun one. One thing that is clear after tonight is that Holey Cream doesn't deserve my business anymore nor does it deserve my recommendations to my friends. In short, although I reported them to Seamless tonight so I will not be charged for this order, I will never, ever again order from them again or recommend them.
Posted 2 years ago by Judi F.
Always amazing and service is always reasonable!
Posted 2 years ago by Dean H.
When it comes to Holey Cream I need an intervention!! Everything on their menu is DELICIOUS. Decadent. Fresh. Phenomenal. The variety is great, the options and sides are are endless. The milkshake variety is mind blowing (birthday cake flavored milkshake!?) I could go on and on. I'm definitely a Holey Cream addict. The delivery aspect could be a little faster though.
Posted 2 years ago by Julie H.
Posted 2 years ago by Marrissa J.
great frozen yogurt. Open late! I"m addicted.
Posted 2 years ago by Evan L.
It is dangerous that ice cream this good can be delivered to my door. I try something new every time I order and I have never been disappointed.
Posted 2 years ago by Deborah M.
Great selection, and quick delivery. The sundaes are the BEST.
Posted 2 years ago by Melissa T.
Not only is Holey Ice Cream delicious but they are also really nice! I placed an order literally at closing time (didnt notice the time) and yet they still delivered a perfect ice cream cone with all the extra gummy bears(and they were generous!) bears I ordered! My new favorite ice cream place! Thank you!!!
Posted 2 years ago by Monica M.
My sundae arrived 40 minutes after I ordered (10 minutes before the 50-65 minute estimate) and the delivery guy still apologized to me, by name, for the wait! Also, it was delicious. Highly recommend.
Posted 2 years ago by Meredith G.
Order was over an hour late and refused to cancel order. Food was terrible and they didn't even send the right things. Worst seamless experience ever. Never again.
Posted 2 years ago by Launa F.
This place has come a long way! In the beginning they would screw up every order, NOW they are spot on and yummy yummy ice cream, yogurt, and oatmeal raisen cookies ROCK!
Posted 2 years ago by Kristin E.
FAT FREE CHOC PEANUT BUTTER FROZEN YOGURT IS AMAZING !!!! highly recommend trying this place if your considering..... I considered for a long time before trying .... Wish I would have sooner.....DELICIOUS FROZEN YOGURT!!! Fast delivery...... Chocolate peanut butter frozen yogurt is out of this world good!
Posted 2 years ago by zoe K.
WRONG ORDER. TOOK FOREVER
Posted 2 years ago by Arielle P.
Truly terrible. Can't even tell you about the dessert since it didn't arrive. Ordered over an hour ago. Won't be doing this again.
Posted 2 years ago by Ria T. D.
Handled with excellent customer service. Would definitely order again!
Posted 2 years ago by Molly A.
Best ice cream in HK!
Posted 2 years ago by John C.
UNREAL. so good.
Posted 2 years ago by Ashley P.
Horrible service. False advertising since their baked goods are not made there and come out of a box (saw it when I walked in there.) Also the owner is really rude and constantly yells at his employees and customers. This is why their delivery tends to be slow.
Posted 2 years ago by Danielle H.
ice cream is fine, please pick up only, the delivery takes well over an hour and its always been made wrong!
Posted 2 years ago by Mark S.
There was a giant curly hair in my ice cream. Otherwise it was great.
Posted 2 years ago by lisa s.
Amazing! Everything was delicious and they even drew a silly image on my ice cream sandwich as I requested :)
Posted 2 years ago by Emily B.
This poor rating is for the manager. The ice cream and bakery items are excellent, but the manager is the most vile person I've ever had to witness. He treats his employees like crap and I won't support this place. He yells, demeans, insults and is generally horrid. The last time we went the really sweet Asian girl that worked there was in the process of quitting. We watched it happen and we couldn't have blamed her one bit. He's the worst. DO NOT support this place.
Posted 3 years ago by Steve M.
Perfect. Arrived quickly and thoroughly satisfied my sweet tooth.
Posted 3 years ago by Selena V.
AMAZING donuts, brownies, and cupcakes!!! all were made fresh to order and were still warm when they arrived! Not usually a fan of store bought baked goods but these were unbelievable
Posted 3 years ago by Meg F.
Utter joke. Hour and a half to deliver after stating 20 minutes. Called and they lied about having sent out the order 5 minutes prior.
Posted 3 years ago by sam a.
Being an adult has it's perks once in a while. One of them is having Holey Cream on Seamless to deliver a nice customized banana split right to my office in the middle of a stressful workweek. It was fast, ice cold and delicious and the delivery guy was polite, professional and friendly. Super excited about my new discovery for when the sweet tooth strikes!
Posted 3 years ago by Heather S.
takes 3hours to deliver
Posted 3 years ago by yeonki k.
Good milkshake and large choice of donuts, which are, at any time, very good.
Posted 3 years ago by SIKSIK P.
Anything you order will be amazing. Will satisfy your sweet tooth and any donut/cookie/ice cream craving
Posted 3 years ago by Chun L.
I am not embarrassed to say that I order delivery from here at least once a week. Everything is amazing. The create your own donut option is unreal!!!
Posted 3 years ago by Jonathan B.
BE WARNED: They NEVER have most of the items listed on their menu! EVER. And most of their cupcakes are stale. Blek! Stay away.
Posted 3 years ago by Jenn B.
Took over an hour to deliver, and it wasn't what I ordered
Posted 3 years ago by Thomas H.
Make your own sundae!!! Red velvet cupcakes!!! Omg.....
Posted 3 years ago by Kareen B.
ice cream is so good and they deliver true to their time also ice cream is never melted by the time it gets here which rulez
Posted 3 years ago by Mohanpal S.
Tasty and awesome. Great dessert delivery, always on time and curtious. Love this little shop.
Posted 3 years ago by adit m.
Finally got a craving for dessert so decided to try this place. Delivery took a long time for an order that was just two flavors of ice cream plus a cappuccino and only needed to go a block. Cappuccino was not available and was substituted for a much cheaper item, a disgusting tasting vanilla flavored regular coffee, without my consent. The "homemade red velvet" ice cream flavor was way too sweet, had an overpowering amount of vanilla flavoring in it, and contained dry, inedible bits of "cake". Pistachio ice cream was fine, but tasted exactly like Ben & Jerry's, at 3 or 4x the cost. Not impressed with this place.
Posted 3 years ago by Simma P.
Who doesn't love an ice cream cone and ALL the fixins' delivered to your door?! Epic.
Posted 3 years ago by Heather G.
Doughnut + Icecream. What can go wrong with that? Tons and tons of different ice cream and even doughnut flavors. Definitely one of my favorite dessert places in the area.
Posted 3 years ago by Jacob C.
Really good when it arrives cold! I know it's hot out, but it shouldn't arrive completely melted
Posted 3 years ago by Michael W.
The vanilla chocolate cookie dough ice cream was delicious... just disappointed that they didn't look at my order and put in the additional add-ins of peanut butter sauce and caramel that I paid for. The toffee cupcake is insanely good.. I ate the whole thing in a single sitting 0:) The Hostess cupcake was a little dry.
Posted 3 years ago by Ashley Y.
FAST delivery - guess it should be for ice cream though, lol
Posted 3 years ago by charlotte U.
Food took 1 hour and 45 minutes to be delivered just a few blocks. Seamless suggested 25-50 minutes.
Posted 3 years ago by Brittany P.
milkshake was too milky. Not enough icecream.
Posted 3 years ago by angela l.
BEST ICE CREAM IN NYC...HANDS DOWN. Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Ice Cream takes dairy to a whole new level.
Posted 3 years ago by Amanda K.
yes, everythings good. but seriously, YOU NEED TO TRY THE DULCE DE LECHE MILKSHAKE. it's not super sweet how most dulce de leche stuff is. it's sweet but totally manageable enough where it won't give you a stomach ache. it's amazing.
Posted 3 years ago by Idalia M.
Average Cookies, average donut, good brownie.
Posted 3 years ago by Rahul P.
The best place ever. Fast delivery and amazing sundaes and donuts!!!!
Posted 3 years ago by Lauren G.
Usually really good but I just got 2 sundaes that were barely 3/4 full. Fo $8 a sundae they should be completely full like usual. Not sure what happened.
Posted 3 years ago by Logan J.
Great desserts--- horrendous delivery, again!
Posted 3 years ago by abby z.
not bad, price was pretty good but not the freshest cupcakes I have ever had.
Posted 3 years ago by Cecilia V.
Great donuts and ice cream! Quick delivery.
Posted 3 years ago by Kimberley F.
My bf & I are hooked. We LOVE the coffee mud pie and order frequently. Sorbets are also very good.
Posted 3 years ago by heather g.
Their ice cream and frozen yogurt is absolutely amazing. Delivery is fast, and one time I called to edit my order and the guy on the phone was really nice. Highly recommended!
Posted 3 years ago by Melissa L.
Their oatmeal raisin ice cream is amazing. Cupcake was good, but I wish I ha ordered more ice cream.
Posted 3 years ago by Javier A.
Crazy good- the milkshakes don't travel well and sometimes delivery takes a while....but you'll be glad in the end.
Posted 3 years ago by stephanie k.
Delicious! The only thing that is quicker than their delivery is how fast their ice cream disappears! Yum yum!
Posted 3 years ago by Lauren T.
Best sorbet I've had in the city.
Posted 3 years ago by Vince C.
The best ice cream around. Luv the Belgian dark chocolate.
Posted 3 years ago by Gary L.
This store is not as close as restaurants we usually order from. Food came quickly.
Best ice cream we have had in a while. Only wish they had peppermint for the holidays!! We will definitely be ordering again when we have dinner guests!!
Posted 3 years ago by Geraldine P.
Posted 4 years ago by Lewis S.
Posted 4 years ago by Atreya C.
the best homemade ice cream, as per usual. Fast delivery time. Pretty sure the delivery man was high.
Posted 4 years ago by Daniel C.
Taste great but can wait forever............
Posted 4 years ago by Nicole L.
I really like this place-I usually go here after hitting 9th avenue for dinner but I've done delivery twice and both times it came fast and delicious! I even tried their donuts and cupcakes for the first time and I loved. Best thing? Their customer service-they didn't have the cupcake flavor I ordered so they gave me the next best thing AND a free cupcake saying thank you! Customer for life now:)
Posted 4 years ago by deana a.
Spotty delivery. I love holey cream for those nights when I'm just too lazy or too busy to walk to the corner deli to get a pint of ice cream. Sundae with hard ice cream is a nice way to reward myself for a hard day at work. I like that you get more then one ice cream choice for the sundae. Didn't care for the donuts, the frosting is a little too sweet for me.
Posted 4 years ago by MS M.
Speedy delivery. Tasty milkshake. You can order up to four different flavors in a pint, which can be good if you make the right choices.
Posted 5 years ago by Erik P.
Terrible and undependable service. Took DOUBLE the time to arrive, which was originally 30-45 minutes. Sooo, after 1.5 hours, the delivery guy came and dropped off the wrong order. He was already gone, once I realized. Called Holey's number and they were not even able to pull up the order. 20 minutes later, the same delivery guy was back...he had given my order to a different apt in my building....
Never ordering from here again.
Posted 5 years ago by lucas k.
took forever for delivery to come, really an hour for icecream? the icecream donut was not very good
Posted 5 years ago by Nan h.
the ice cream and frozen yogurt are great, but they screw up my order at least 50% of the time. And often nobody picks up the phone to resolve the situation. I would love to give them a 5 star review, but the unbelievable consistency with which they screw up my order doesn't merit 5 stars.
Posted 5 years ago by Alisa M.
The ice cream was good, although the service was seriously lacking. For the $10 I paid, definitely not worth it.
First, the order came 1 hr, 15 mins late, which means partially melted ice cream. Second, I ordered a large and I got this small/medium sized cup, with a large top, improperly fitted on it resulting in ice cream spilling out of the cup and making a mess in the bag!! For what I paid, I definitely should have gotten more than melted ice cream in my bag, compounded with late service.
Posted 5 years ago by Kaity A.
took almost an hour and a half to deliver ice cream...
Posted 5 years ago by Michelle C.
Good some times slow
Posted 5 years ago by Richard H.
Very tasty with lots of options, but the price can definitely add up when you consider you're ordering a snack!
Posted 5 years ago by Kelly T.
Great concept. Love the variety of ice cream flavors. Delivery can be a little slow (though every time we have ordered there has been bad weather which may be a factor...)
Posted 5 years ago by Ricky P.
Food came very quickly and their red velvet cupcake was amazing!
Posted 5 years ago by Shayla M.
very slow. who wants to wait an hour and 20 minutes for delivery?
Posted 5 years ago by Bill K.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Holey Cream's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.