Online ordering powered by Seamless
796 NINTH AVE, (9th Ave Between 51st and 52nd Streets)(212) 247-8400
Minimum order of $11.00 is required for delivery
+ $0.75 delivery fee (more info)
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $11.00 is required for delivery
+ $0.75 delivery fee (more info)
Delivery estimate is 35 - 50 min (more info)
Print this menu
Choice of two or more flavors.
Holey Cream is well known in Midtown for offering unique and outstanding sweet treats. Holey Cream is open late so that no matter what time you’re craving a delicious treat, they can always satisfy your hunger. The Specialty Sundaes, Ice Cream Donut Sandwiches, and Milk Shakes are all prepared quickly and delivered to you right away. Holey Cream uses only the freshest ingredients around, ensuring that every dish is of the highest possible quality. Be sure to try the best selling Fat Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Ice Cream and see why customers are always coming back for more. Order online or stop by Holey Cream today!
This poor rating is for the manager. The ice cream and bakery items are excellent, but the manager is the most vile person I've ever had to witness. He treats his employees like crap and I won't support this place. He yells, demeans, insults and is generally horrid. The last time we went the really sweet Asian girl that worked there was in the process of quitting. We watched it happen and we couldn't have blamed her one bit. He's the worst. DO NOT support this place.
Posted a week ago by Steve M.
Perfect. Arrived quickly and thoroughly satisfied my sweet tooth.
Posted a week ago by Selena V.
AMAZING donuts, brownies, and cupcakes!!! all were made fresh to order and were still warm when they arrived! Not usually a fan of store bought baked goods but these were unbelievable
Posted 2 weeks ago by Meg F.
Utter joke. Hour and a half to deliver after stating 20 minutes. Called and they lied about having sent out the order 5 minutes prior.
Posted 3 weeks ago by sam a.
Being an adult has it's perks once in a while. One of them is having Holey Cream on Seamless to deliver a nice customized banana split right to my office in the middle of a stressful workweek. It was fast, ice cold and delicious and the delivery guy was polite, professional and friendly. Super excited about my new discovery for when the sweet tooth strikes!
Posted 3 weeks ago by Heather S.
takes 3hours to deliver
Posted a month ago by yeonki k.
Good milkshake and large choice of donuts, which are, at any time, very good.
Posted a month ago by SIKSIK P.
High recommend trying this place if your considering..... I considered for a long time before trying .... Wish I would have sooner.....DELICIOUS FROZEN YOGURT!!! Fast delivery...... Chocolate peanut butter frozen yogurt is out of this world good!
Posted a month ago by zoe K.
No better Ice Cream in NYC!! We ordered it during a snow storm.
Posted a month ago by Dean H.
Never showed up
Posted 2 months ago by Nikki L.
Took almost 1.5 hours to deliver order.
Posted 2 months ago by Robert C.
I have ordered from here several times. This time my order was completely wrong. I call the restaurant and the staff was extremely disrespectful telling me to call seamless with my problems. This will be my last order from this place because of it.
Posted 2 months ago by Jaime F.
Anything you order will be amazing. Will satisfy your sweet tooth and any donut/cookie/ice cream craving
Posted 2 months ago by Chun L.
I am not embarrassed to say that I order delivery from here at least once a week. Everything is amazing. The create your own donut option is unreal!!!
Posted 3 months ago by Jonathan B.
BE WARNED: They NEVER have most of the items listed on their menu! EVER. And most of their cupcakes are stale. Blek! Stay away.
Posted 3 months ago by Jenn B.
Milkshakes were melted by the time they arrived. Very disappointing.
Posted 4 months ago by Jeremy S.
Took over an hour to deliver, and it wasn't what I ordered
Posted 4 months ago by Thomas H.
Make your own sundae!!! Red velvet cupcakes!!! Omg.....
Posted 4 months ago by Kareen B.
ice cream is so good and they deliver true to their time also ice cream is never melted by the time it gets here which rulez
Posted 4 months ago by Gurbani C.
Horrible.... ice creme melted and takes 2 and half hours to get here
Posted 4 months ago by Matthew H.
Holey Cream is my guilty pleasure and has been for the past two years. However, this summer every order has been delivered incomplete and/or much later than promised when ordered. I've lost faith in their ability to fill an order. :(
Posted 4 months ago by Christian Q.
Tasty and awesome. Great dessert delivery, always on time and curtious. Love this little shop.
Posted 5 months ago by adit m.
Finally got a craving for dessert so decided to try this place. Delivery took a long time for an order that was just two flavors of ice cream plus a cappuccino and only needed to go a block. Cappuccino was not available and was substituted for a much cheaper item, a disgusting tasting vanilla flavored regular coffee, without my consent. The "homemade red velvet" ice cream flavor was way too sweet, had an overpowering amount of vanilla flavoring in it, and contained dry, inedible bits of "cake". Pistachio ice cream was fine, but tasted exactly like Ben & Jerry's, at 3 or 4x the cost. Not impressed with this place.
Posted 5 months ago by Simma P.
Who doesn't love an ice cream cone and ALL the fixins' delivered to your door?! Epic.
Posted 5 months ago by Heather G.
Doughnut + Icecream. What can go wrong with that? Tons and tons of different ice cream and even doughnut flavors. Definitely one of my favorite dessert places in the area.
Posted 5 months ago by Jacob C.
Really good when it arrives cold! I know it's hot out, but it shouldn't arrive completely melted
Posted 5 months ago by Michael W.
The vanilla chocolate cookie dough ice cream was delicious... just disappointed that they didn't look at my order and put in the additional add-ins of peanut butter sauce and caramel that I paid for. The toffee cupcake is insanely good.. I ate the whole thing in a single sitting 0:) The Hostess cupcake was a little dry.
Posted 5 months ago by Ashley Y.
they gave me the wrong order and i couldn't get through to call back because they had already closed.
Posted 5 months ago by Veronica M.
FAST delivery - guess it should be for ice cream though, lol
Posted 6 months ago by charlotte U.
Horrible. Waited two hours and called. Holley crime had no visibility into what my order was even though I got email confirm. I recommend saving your time and money than bothering with this place
Posted 6 months ago by Ross S.
Food took 1 hour and 45 minutes to be delivered just a few blocks. Seamless suggested 25-50 minutes.
Posted 6 months ago by Brittany P.
milkshake was too milky. Not enough icecream.
Posted 6 months ago by angela l.
Absolutely terrible delivery and customer service. I was hung up on twice when call about my order. Delivery took well over 1 hr 30 mins.
Posted 6 months ago by Abbey H.
yogurt tasted old-not friendly in the store
Posted 6 months ago by Scott W.
BEST ICE CREAM IN NYC...HANDS DOWN. Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Ice Cream takes dairy to a whole new level.
Posted 6 months ago by Amanda K.
Delivery time terrible! I have been waiting an hour and 20 minutes for a cupcake and a smoothie which was supposed to take 30-50 mins. When i called, the guy who answered just said that the delivery guy was on his way with no explanation of why so late. I live in midtown right next to rockefeller center. On top of this i even gave a $3 tip on a $10 order! There is no excuse for this!!
Posted 6 months ago by Stephanie G.
yes, everythings good. but seriously, YOU NEED TO TRY THE DULCE DE LECHE MILKSHAKE. it's not super sweet how most dulce de leche stuff is. it's sweet but totally manageable enough where it won't give you a stomach ache. it's amazing.
Posted 7 months ago by Idalia M.
Average Cookies, average donut, good brownie.
Posted 7 months ago by Rahul P.
The best place ever. Fast delivery and amazing sundaes and donuts!!!!
Posted 7 months ago by Lauren G.
1-star is sadly the lowest possible rating, because Holey Creme hands down had the worst service I've ever received anywhere. And I've backpacked through third world countries and near-war zones.
Nor was this an isolated incident -- Holey Creme has managed to make poor service a tradition. Will definitely never order from here again.
Posted 7 months ago by Jason C.
Usually really good but I just got 2 sundaes that were barely 3/4 full. Fo $8 a sundae they should be completely full like usual. Not sure what happened.
Posted 7 months ago by Logan J.
Great desserts--- horrendous delivery, again!
Posted 7 months ago by abby z.
not bad, price was pretty good but not the freshest cupcakes I have ever had.
Posted 8 months ago by Cecilia V.
Great donuts and ice cream! Quick delivery.
Posted 8 months ago by Kimberley F.
My bf & I are hooked. We LOVE the coffee mud pie and order frequently. Sorbets are also very good.
Posted 8 months ago by heather g.
Their ice cream and frozen yogurt is absolutely amazing. Delivery is fast, and one time I called to edit my order and the guy on the phone was really nice. Highly recommended!
Posted 8 months ago by Melissa L.
Their oatmeal raisin ice cream is amazing. Cupcake was good, but I wish I ha ordered more ice cream.
Posted 8 months ago by Javier A.
Crazy good- the milkshakes don't travel well and sometimes delivery takes a while....but you'll be glad in the end.
Posted 10 months ago by stephanie k.
Delicious! The only thing that is quicker than their delivery is how fast their ice cream disappears! Yum yum!
Posted 10 months ago by Lauren T.
Milkshake tasted rancid. The cookies were okay but grocery store quality.
Posted 10 months ago by daniel k.
Best sorbet I've had in the city.
Posted 10 months ago by Vince C.
Posted 10 months ago by Michael T.
An hour and a half wait to have the order completely wrong.
Posted 10 months ago by Randy B.
The best ice cream around. Luv the Belgian dark chocolate.
Posted 11 months ago by Gary L.
This store is not as close as restaurants we usually order from. Food came quickly.
Best ice cream we have had in a while. Only wish they had peppermint for the holidays!! We will definitely be ordering again when we have dinner guests!!
Posted 11 months ago by tanya w.
Posted a year ago by Lewis S.
Totally unreliable. Waited an hour only to be told they couldn't deliver my order for at least another half hour.
Posted a year ago by Jennifer F.
Posted a year ago by Atreya C.
the best homemade ice cream, as per usual. Fast delivery time. Pretty sure the delivery man was high.
Posted a year ago by Daniel C.
Taste great but can wait forever............
Posted a year ago by Nicole L.
have ordered here several times and will say that the ice cream is fantastic, but the delivery speed is not. Ordered tonight at 9:21pm. Called the place at 10:21pm and was told that our ice cream left the restaurant 23 mins ago and that it would be to our place any second. A total of an hour and 15 mins later we got our ice cream. By this time, the ice cream was melted. One of the milkshakes had exploded in the bag and was completely empty. Overall terrible experience although I would not be writing this review if the guy on the phone wasn't so rude and just seemed a little apologetic.
Posted a year ago by Michael C.
I really like this place-I usually go here after hitting 9th avenue for dinner but I've done delivery twice and both times it came fast and delicious! I even tried their donuts and cupcakes for the first time and I loved. Best thing? Their customer service-they didn't have the cupcake flavor I ordered so they gave me the next best thing AND a free cupcake saying thank you! Customer for life now:)
Posted a year ago by deana a.
Just had my first experience and oh my god I'll be back!!! Delivery was fast and the guy was so so nice! Brownie sundae was to die for as was the cookies and cream milkshake! YUM!
Posted a year ago by Ali C.
birthday cake ice cream is amazing. The donut was made to order. delicious
Posted a year ago by justin d.
I love Holey Cream. The donuts, cupcakes, and ice cream are all excellent. The only times I've had trouble with delivery or an order (item ordered not available or delayed delivery), they've thrown in a free cupcake for the trouble.
Posted a year ago by Tim C.
I LOVE the pistachio ice cream. The best pistachio ice cream/gelato I ever had was in Italy and this comes second to that. I also order the Razzo Mango Smoothie. The blend of fruits in the smoothie are a great combination, and its delicious.
Not only are the ice cream and smoothies amazing, the delivery man was also really nice. He was holding only my bag when I opened the door and carefully from the bottom. He said "I hope you enjoy, it's a good one!" and then proceeded to reach for the other orders he had hidden out of my sight. Definitely someone who is focused on customer service.
Posted a year ago by Soyoung L.
Took double the time stated. Estimated 30min to 50 and now over1.5 hrs later and no ice cream!
Posted a year ago by kerry m.
Possibly one of the best ice cream places on earth. Good selection of both standard ice cream flavors and frozen yogurt. Plus a small selection of some of the best home made icecream i've ever had. plus some of the most decedent stuff one can eat with ice cream (donuts? sundaes with more stuff than even a group of people can eat). Portions are reasonable (not overwhelming) and price is good considering the quality. Always bring any friends or family here whenever they are around or in town. 5 stars.
Posted a year ago by Sean Z.
I order a hot fudge sundae quite often and I like to grab some of the homemade ice cream and a couple cupcakes. Delivery is usually much quicker than estimated and I have never been disappointed in the delivery quality. The portion of the sundae is crazy and would satisfy anyone.
Posted a year ago by Erik N.
Spotty delivery. I love holey cream for those nights when I'm just too lazy or too busy to walk to the corner deli to get a pint of ice cream. Sundae with hard ice cream is a nice way to reward myself for a hard day at work. I like that you get more then one ice cream choice for the sundae. Didn't care for the donuts, the frosting is a little too sweet for me.
Posted a year ago by MS M.
Great Fast Service. The Fat Free Chocloate Peanut Butter Chip Frozen Yogurt is to die for.
Posted a year ago by joyce n.
ZERO ZERO ZERO This is the 3rd time i have ordered from them and they either are out of it or they can't deliver it.
Dont wast your time or money!!!
Posted a year ago by TODD K.
Terrible Service! They got our order wrong twice. After the second time, we didn't want to wait for it again, so we asked for our money back, but they refused to give us a refund. This overpriced ice cream isn't worth it since they got rid of the oatmeal cookie flavor anyway. I'm going to leave it to my credit card to get my money back for the food I never got.
Posted a year ago by Irina V.
Seriously. Why does it take an hour and a half to deliver ice cream...and counting it's not even here yet!!!
Posted 2 years ago by Betty M.
Speedy delivery. Tasty milkshake. You can order up to four different flavors in a pint, which can be good if you make the right choices.
Posted 2 years ago by Erik P.
Amazing ice cream. Love their non fat peanut butter chocolate ice cream. Their oatmeal raisin cookie ice cream is without question the best ice cream I have ever had. Changed my rating because they haven't had the oatmeal raisin ice cream for over a month now but keep saying it will be back any day.
Posted 2 years ago by Dan o.
Delivery takes too long - but the ice cream is delicious. Prices are very high and on 2 occasions in the past month they have forgotten to deliver half my order
Posted 2 years ago by Andrea S.
Over two hours! awful
Posted 2 years ago by Thomas M.
i wish i had read the reviews. service is absolutely terrible. Almost 2 hours for ice crem delivery 8 blocks away. Message to seamless. if a rst says 30 mins and they consistently take 3-4x longer, you should contact merchant or take them of seamless.
Posted 2 years ago by D W.
Terrible and undependable service. Took DOUBLE the time to arrive, which was originally 30-45 minutes. Sooo, after 1.5 hours, the delivery guy came and dropped off the wrong order. He was already gone, once I realized. Called Holey's number and they were not even able to pull up the order. 20 minutes later, the same delivery guy was back...he had given my order to a different apt in my building....
Never ordering from here again.
Posted 2 years ago by lucas k.
This place has never delivered within the delivery estimate time. Tonight, the quote was 30-45 minutes and it took an hour. Once the order arrived I asked if I needed to sign anything and the delivery guy said no, which always makes me nervous because then I don't get a chance to check the order before he leaves. Sure enough, order wrong. Worst thing is that when my boyfriend called to let them know, the guy on the phone wasn't apologetic and said it would take another 40 minutes (aka hour) because they're "really busy." Who cares? We paid for an order an hour ago and it's not our fault you screwed up. After many late orders, this will be our last. I'll only consider this company again if I'm walking by and feel like picking something up.
Posted 2 years ago by Nicole P.
took forever for delivery to come, really an hour for icecream? the icecream donut was not very good
Posted 2 years ago by Nan h.
would get 5 stars for the food, but every delivery is at least an hour. not worth the wait
Posted 2 years ago by Nick C.
This place is AMAZING. Great ice cream and frozen yogurt. They are also very helpful. When they are behind on orders, they call and ask if you still want the order. Very nice and friendly. I would recommend to anyone in the area!!
Posted 2 years ago by Amanda B.
the ice cream and frozen yogurt are great, but they screw up my order at least 50% of the time. And often nobody picks up the phone to resolve the situation. I would love to give them a 5 star review, but the unbelievable consistency with which they screw up my order doesn't merit 5 stars.
Posted 2 years ago by Alisa M.
this is the best ice cream in the city hands down. from the incredible red velvet ice cream to the smores to the blueberry ripple...each flavor is incredible and so creamy!
love it! will always order from here.
Posted 2 years ago by Stephanie S.
The ice cream was good, although the service was seriously lacking. For the $10 I paid, definitely not worth it.
First, the order came 1 hr, 15 mins late, which means partially melted ice cream. Second, I ordered a large and I got this small/medium sized cup, with a large top, improperly fitted on it resulting in ice cream spilling out of the cup and making a mess in the bag!! For what I paid, I definitely should have gotten more than melted ice cream in my bag, compounded with late service.
Posted 2 years ago by Kaity A.
took almost an hour and a half to deliver ice cream...
Posted 2 years ago by Michelle C.
Good some times slow
Posted 2 years ago by Richard H.
Very tasty with lots of options, but the price can definitely add up when you consider you're ordering a snack!
Posted 2 years ago by Kelly T.
There are so many options at Holey Cream. It is an inventive and special ice cream restaurant. It is open late, they deliver and they have a lot of frozen yogurt for those who do not partake in ice cream eating. And everyone who works there is really friendly. They are speedy and efficient.
Posted 2 years ago by Carrie A.
I am addicted to Holey Cream! Haven't had a flavor that I don't LOVE! I especially love the peanut butter chocolate chip frozen yogurt, and I'm typically not someone who counts calories or cares if something is fat-free, but this frozen yogurt is unbelievable. I have to stop myself from ordering from here every single night!
Posted 2 years ago by Jimmy M.
Great concept. Love the variety of ice cream flavors. Delivery can be a little slow (though every time we have ordered there has been bad weather which may be a factor...)
Posted 2 years ago by Ricky P.
Their chocolate peanut butter frozen yogurt (fat free version) is so delicious! It doesn't taste fat free at all, I am heavenly surprised! Also, their donut ice cream sandwich are the best. Very addicting. The only thing I wouldn't order again is the fat free smoothie. It says select 2 fruits. This is misleading because what i got was in fact artificial flavoring of the fruits! Other than that, this place has really good ice cream =).
Posted 2 years ago by Suk H.
awesome... your trainer will kill u, but its worth it
Posted 2 years ago by jon B.
Delicious ice cream...delivered? Don't mind if I Duluth.
Posted 2 years ago by Jake P.
These desserts are decadent, and I love all the different ice cream flavors, toppings, and icing choices.
Posted 2 years ago by Olivier C.
Awesome frozen yogurt.. Extensive menu with lots of choices.. Quick and accurate delivery..
Posted 2 years ago by LIZ S.
This spot was great and served my wife's late night craving for sweets. Given the price she thought the order was for 6 donut holes but actually it was 6 huge donuts so she was thrilled. I would definitely order from here again and would recommend it for those late night sweet cravings!
Posted 2 years ago by Alexander C.
Took very long to deliver and sent me wrong order.
Posted 2 years ago by Sisi L.
Food came very quickly and their red velvet cupcake was amazing!
Posted 2 years ago by Shayla M.
Fantastic ice cream and sorbet, and well-packaged for delivery.
Posted 2 years ago by Mike S.
Dont get delivery. Better to go there
Posted 2 years ago by Brooks R.
Amazing! Order now!
Posted 2 years ago by Nitesh Y.
very slow. who wants to wait an hour and 20 minutes for delivery?
Posted 2 years ago by Bill K.
this place is wonderful! delicious donuts AND icecream! its the perfect satisfaction for even the strongest dessert cravings. lovelovelove it.
Posted 2 years ago by clara l.
Absolutely love this place... And, I recently went to the store and found out they now sell cupcakes, cookies and brownies...OH MY! I will keep ordering from this place!
Posted 2 years ago by Marni F.
Best fat free chocolate peanut butter chip frozen yogurt ever! Can't believe it is frozen yogurt! Delivery was super fast and ice cream looked like I just walked out of the store! Definitely a great place! I will be a weekly customer!
Posted 2 years ago by marni f.
Donuts. Ice cream. Ice cream ON donuts. Awesome.
Posted 3 years ago by John R.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Holey Cream's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from
Holey Cream by entering your address
below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.